5 Spots for Tasty Sandwiches

The sandwich is much more than just two slices of bread with some processed meat and cheese inside. From irresistible egg sandwiches topped with hickory-smoked sausage to traditional authentic heroes, Brooklyn offers numerous remarkable eateries to indulge in delicious sandwiches. Consequently, skip the conventional fast-food sandwich shop and opt for these uniquely crafted and authentic Brooklyn sandwich experiences.

01. Red Star Sandwich Shop

Address: 2028 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226, USA

Phone: +1 718-826-8818

Red Star Sandwich Shop

This Asian-American sandwich shop located on Smith Street in Boerum Hill has a comforting food menu coupled with a warm vibe. Order at the counter, grab a board game, and enjoy your Korean Fried Chicken Sandwich along with tater tots. Vegetarians should try the Shitake Fried Tofu sandwich, known for its flavor and heartiness. They also offer a solid selection of craft beers.

02. Defonte’s Sandwich Shop

Address: 379 Columbia St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

Phone: +1 718-625-8052

For an authentic Brooklyn hero, visit Defonte’s in Red Hook. As a neighborhood institution, it has been serving heroes since the 1920s. Although the menu is straightforward, the quality is exceptional. Craving an eggplant parmesan hero? This is the place to be. Even though it’s slightly off the beaten path, the adventure is worth it. The establishment has been featured on the Food Network, solidifying its classic reputation.

03. The Meathook Sandwich Shop

Address: 397 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211-2421, USA

Phone: +1 718-609-9300

Visit website

Located next to a butcher shop, The Meathook Sandwich Shop in Williamsburg is a paradise for meat lovers. Leave your vegetarian friends behind and treat yourself to sumptuous roast beef sandwiches and other meaty favorites. After your meal, take a leisurely stroll around this trendy Brooklyn area.

04. The Sandwich Shop

Address: 658A Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA

Phone: +1 917-932-5662

The Sandwich Shop

This cozy establishment in Williamsburg provides an extensive menu that includes everything from classic tuna sandwiches to the signature “Southern Spice,” a delightful assembly of pulled pork on a Chipotle base topped with melted Cheddar cheese and coleslaw on hand-cut brioche. After dining, wander around Manhattan Avenue to discover various unique shops. A recommended stop for food enthusiasts is Archestratus, a wonderful cookbook bookstore and café where you can grab dessert.

05. Court Street Grocers

Address: 378 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA

Phone: +1 833-533-3200

Court Street Grocers

This unpretentious grocer located on Court Street in Carroll Gardens may serve some of the best sandwiches in Brooklyn. Whether you’re stopping for a tasty breakfast sandwich or a satisfying lunch, this spot won’t disappoint. With additional locations in Carroll Gardens, Red Hook, and Greenwich Village, it’s an ideal destination for enjoying a delectable sandwich. As a fan, I must say I am slightly addicted to their Veg Classic, featuring a mushroom and black bean patty, American cheese, full sour pickles, red onion, bibb lettuce, and “come-back” sauce on a Martin’s potato roll. Don’t forget to grab a tote bag on your way out to blend in with the locals!