Which Hawaiian Island is Best for You?

The islands in Hawaii are dream-worthy. The diversity of each isle is fascinating, from pristine beaches to snow-capped mountains and even active volcanoes. Hawaii has six major islands – Kauai, Molokai, Lanai, Maui, the Big Island, and Oahu, each offering unique attractions and experiences across all the Hawaiian islands. This variety can make it really difficult to choose just one.

Each Hawaiian island has a distinct character and different reasons to visit. For instance, the Big Island is home to Volcanoes National Park, making it a great option for those looking to hike an active volcano. Others are better known for luxury beach resorts (Maui has particularly luxurious resorts). Therefore, when selecting the best island to visit in Hawaii, you should consider what kind of trip you want.

Hawaiian Islands to Visit

This guide will help you choose the best island to visit in Hawaii. All the islands in Hawaii are stunning, but in a world that usually leaves us short on time and budget, chances are you need to narrow things down. Let’s find your match made in paradise.

Regenerative Tourism

Recently, the implementation of Regenerative Tourism took effect in May of 2022. The idea behind this initiative is two-fold: to give back to the communities on the Hawaiian islands and to manage the traffic and over-tourism challenges facing the state. Consequently, this means that visitors will now need to make reservations in advance when it comes to some of the most popular locations.

For example, if you want to visit Diamond Head Monument for the amazing views over Waikiki Beach, you will have to reserve a 2-hour time slot. Sunrise viewing at Haleakala National Park also requires a reservation, which can be made up to 60 days in advance at recreation.gov. The cost is $1, in addition to the per-vehicle fee of $30. However, other than sunrise viewing from 3-7 AM, reservations are not necessary.

This additional planning for your Hawaiian islands trip may be tedious, but it also aids in preserving these beautiful locations for future generations. Make sure to check all main attractions for reservation requirements to ensure you don’t miss out. See the Division of State Parks for openings and closures.

1. Big Island

The Big Island (or Hawaii Island) is the largest in the Hawaiian archipelago. Many believe it is the best Hawaii Island for first-timers, home to a host of beautiful natural attractions. Despite being the youngest island in the Hawaiian archipelago, the Big Island is a hub of diverse experiences. At twice the size of all the other islands combined, it’s easy to see how it earned its nickname.

Big Island is renowned for its volcanoes and stunning beaches. It features both Hawaii’s Volcanoes National Park and two active volcanoes, and if you are fortunate, you might even spot flowing lava (Hawaii is the only island where you can see lava). Furthermore, this island boasts numerous green and black sand beaches to explore, offering a comprehensive taste of what makes Hawaii famous, all in one location. If you seek an island with a ‘have it all’ vibe, the Big Island checks many boxes. Plus, it is the most accessible island, with plenty of direct flights from around the globe.

Things to do on The Big Island

When visiting the Big Island, numerous activities await you. Explore Hawaii Volcanoes National Park to witness the power of active volcanoes. Snorkeling at Kealakekua Bay provides an opportunity to see vibrant marine life. Do not miss the chance to visit the black sand beach at Punaluʻu, a unique attraction stemming from volcanic activity. Additionally, unwind at beautiful beaches, hike through lush rainforests, and stargaze at Mauna Kea.

At a quick glance:

• Hiking in Volcanoes National Park
• Exploring lava tunnels at Kula Kai Caverns
• Stargazing at Mauna Kea, the world’s largest observatory
• Snorkeling with Manta Rays at Night

The Big Island presents many exciting things to do, with a collection of attractions that encapsulate the very best of the Hawaiian archipelago. First and foremost, visiting Hawaii Volcanoes National Park is essential; embark on scenic hikes, see flowing lava, and participate in educational programs. The hiking trails in the park are among the most picturesque in Hawaii.

Next, explore Kula Kai Caverns, an extensive network of old lava caves carved out by past eruptions. These caverns provide insight into the island’s geological and cultural history, as indigenous people once sought shelter within them. For similar experiences on the island’s east side, head to Kaumana Caves or Kilauea Caverns of Fire.

Finally, do not miss Mauna Kea, home to the world’s largest observatory featuring 13 telescopes. Stargazing here reveals stunning celestial views—definitely a highlight of visiting the Big Island.

Where to Stay on the Big Island

When it comes to accommodation, the Big Island offers a wide variety, ranging from hostels to luxurious resorts. Here are some top suggestions.

Volcano Inn is a unique spot to consider on the Big Island. This four-star property provides cozy yet luxurious quarters on the outskirts of Volcanoes National Park. The property is self-contained, ensuring privacy and tranquility, with charming wooden features blending into its rainforest surroundings.

Pele’s Hana ‘Ana Hostel is relatively new but has received excellent reviews. It features bright, comfortable interiors at reasonable prices, making it perfect for budget travelers. Located next to a café, it offers easy access to meals and is just a twenty-minute drive from the volcanoes and stunning hikes.

2. Maui

As the second-largest island in Hawaii, Maui is popular for its vibrant tourist scene and exciting attractions. Often referred to as ‘The Valley Isle,’ it has been voted the ‘best island in Hawaii’ by luxury travel magazine Conde Nast Traveler for over 20 years. Maui is renowned for its breathtaking beauty and reliable indicators suggesting you’ll have an unforgettable experience if you choose this island.

Boasting spectacular attractions on land, Maui is home to Hawaii’s tallest mountain, Haleakala, the famed Hana Highway, and serene waterfall hikes. However, its true charm lies in its stunning beaches, wildlife-rich oceans, and picturesque coastal views. Popular for whale-watching tours, Maui hosts the densest humpback whale population globally, especially from November to May.

Things to do on The Valley Isle

At a quick glance:

• Whale watching
• Witnessing the sunrise at Haleakala National Park
• Driving the scenic Road to Hana Highway

One of the top activities in Maui is whale watching, particularly between November and May, with January to March being the optimal time. Most whale-watching tours leave from West Maui’s coastal areas, such as Kaanapali. Ensure to capture the unforgettable moment of spotting a humpback whale on camera.

Another highlight is hiking in Haleakala National Park, home to the dormant volcano Haleakala, which stands at 10,023 feet, marking the highest point in Hawaii. Sunrise views from this summit are unforgettable, making it necessary to consider a guided tour that typically includes breakfast.

Driving the Road to Hana Highway is yet another incredible experience. The drive can take 10 to 12 hours, and it’s wise to rent a car with multiple drivers on the insurance to allow for rotation. Alternatively, you can drive one way and spend the night in Hana before returning.

This famous road winds along Maui’s north coast, treating travelers to a stunning coastal highway experience through jungles, bamboo forests, and past pristine waterfalls. The route features numerous stop-off points, including the Garden of Eden Arboretum, Waikani Falls, and Hana Lava Tube.

Where to stay on Maui

Maui offers luxury accommodations and classic resorts for those with a taste for opulence. Four Seasons Resort Maui at Wailea stands out, featuring three outdoor swimming pools, exquisite dining options, tennis courts, and a spa and wellness center. Each room is designed with natural features, creating a sublime environment for relaxation.

For mid-range to budget accommodations, two main hostels are available: Howzit Hostels and Tiki Beach Hostel. Howzit is slightly cheaper yet located outside the city center, while Tiki Beach Hostel is more expensive but found in Lahaina’s heart.

3. Kauai

Kauai may not be the largest Hawaiian island, but it compensates with stunning natural beauty. Known as the “Garden Isle,” Kauai has been featured in numerous Hollywood movies, primarily due to its breathtaking Na Pali Coast. With its spectacular beaches, dramatic cliffs, and coastal scenery, Kauai provides visitors an opportunity to embrace the great outdoors.

Things to do in Kauai

At a quick glance:

• Hiking the Kalalau Trail
• Visiting Waimea Canyon State Park
• Crossing the Hanapepe Swinging Bridge

No visit to Kauai would be complete without experiencing the Na Pali Coast. Various viewpoints along the coastline offer breathtaking views; a thrilling helicopter tour can provide an exciting aerial perspective. For outdoor enthusiasts, the Kalalau Trail presents a challenging 11-mile hike showcasing the coastline, ideal for seasoned hikers.

Waimea Canyon State Park, often dubbed the ‘Grand Canyon of the Pacific,’ features stunning red rock formations and lush rainforests. Numerous trails allow you to explore the canyon up close or appreciate the view from several driving lookouts.

Crossing the Hanapepe Swinging Bridge is an essential stop, offering an iconic Kauai experience. Initially built to improve residents’ access to the opposite riverbank, this nostalgic bridge has become a popular landmark.

Where to stay on Kauai

For accommodations, Kauai appeals to mid-range to luxury budgets. While hostels like Kauai Beach House Hostel exist, most options involve three to four-star hotels averaging around $200 per night. Booking in advance is recommended as accommodations can fill up quickly.

If you’re seeking luxury, Koloa Landing Resort at Po‘ipu offers stunning views and exceptional amenities, including vast swimming pools and beautifully landscaped grounds. This resort blends the best of nature with top-tier comfort.

4. Oahu

Oahu is known as a bustling metropolis with its capital city, Honolulu, aptly nicknamed ‘the Gathering Place.’ As the most populated island in the Hawaiian archipelago, Oahu offers a residential atmosphere typically seen in urban environments. It boasts a plethora of attractions related to politics, history, and modern-day Hawaii, along with the Daniel K. Inouye International Airport—often the first point of contact for many visitors.

Despite its urban vibe, Oahu provides numerous sandy beaches and enchanting scenery. While the south shore is lively, the north shore offers a tranquil escape with coastal towns and Turtle Bay. Oahu also has many historical and political attractions and opportunities for relaxation amid the city bustle.

Things to do on Oahu

At a quick glance:

• Pay your respects at the Pearl Harbor National Memorial
• Relax on Waikiki Beach
• Learn about Hawaii’s monarchy at Iolani Palace

Among Oahu’s notable attractions is the Pearl Harbor memorial, commemorating the attack in 1941. Visitors can learn more about the tragedy and its significance in WWII at the museum. A trip to Pearl Harbor is considered a must-do when visiting this vibrant island.

Waikiki Beach, renowned for its iconic surf and picturesque palm trees, serves as both a vibrant gathering spot and an ideal location for surfing lessons. Alternatively, if you seek challenging waves, head to the North Shore.

Iolani Palace serves as another significant attraction where you can learn more about Hawaii’s royal history—once home to Queen Lili‘uokalani.

Where to stay on Oahu

If luxury appeals to you, Halepuna Waikiki by Halekulani is a fantastic hotel choice. This property features beautiful artwork, an infinity lap pool, and a well-equipped gym and spa. Conversely, the Polynesian Hostel Beach Club provides dormitory rooms at competitive prices, ideal for those traveling solo seeking new friendships.

5. Lanai

As one of the smallest Hawaiian islands, Lanai is nicknamed the ‘Pineapple Island’ due to its plantation history, once producing 75% of the world’s pineapples. Approximately 98% of Lanai is privately owned by Larry Ellison, creating an exclusive atmosphere. Nevertheless, visitors can plan trips to Lanai, where luxury resorts boast world-class facilities, including championship golf courses.

While primarily a private resort island, Lanai offers a remarkable selection of wildlife. Spinner dolphins and turtles are often spotted along its beautiful shores. Lanai is easily accessible, just a short journey from Maui, making it the perfect addition to a Hawaiian itinerary.

Things to do on Lanai

At a quick glance:

• Exploring the Garden of the Gods
• Snorkeling at Hulopoe Beach
• Taking a helicopter tour

While Lanai is almost entirely privately owned, various activities for tourists are available. The Garden of the Gods presents a unique desert landscape, ideal for exploring via 4WD. Ensure your resort excursions cover this stunning area.

For an authentic tropical experience, head to Hulopoe Beach with its calm waters, perfect for swimming and snorkeling in a protected marine preserve.

Lastly, indulge in a helicopter tour for unparalleled views of Lanai and surrounding islands—an unforgettable way to witness Hawaii from above.

Where to stay on Lanai

Your primary accommodation option is the Four Seasons Resort Lanai, a five-star luxury resort that promises a fantastic experience. With two outdoor pools, a championship golf course, and stargazing options, this property offers premium comfort.

If mid-range accommodations are more your style, Hotel Lanai features plantation-style rooms and a cozy ambiance, making it a charming retreat.

6. Molokai

Molokai presents a unique opportunity for travelers interested in conservation and sustainability. If you wish to engage with Hawaii’s sustainability programs rather than visiting solely for leisure, Molokai is the ideal choice. This largely uninhabited island provides a safe haven for some of Hawaii’s most remote natural areas.

The island has a complex history, having once served as a leper colony. Today, visitors can learn about Hawaiian history, culture, and conservation efforts on Molokai, ideal for those seeking a more ethically responsible experience of the Hawaiian islands.

Things to do on Molokai

At a quick glance:

• Hiking in the Molokai Forest Reserve
• Learning at the Molokai Museum and Cultural Center
• Walking the stunning Papohaku Beach Park

With limited tourist infrastructure, Molokai focuses on preserving its natural landscape. The Molokai Museum and Cultural Center provides valuable insights into the island’s history, particularly concerning Hansen’s disease and the sugar industry’s impact.

Nature enthusiasts will cherish the Molokai Forest Reserve, home to hiking trails, guided tours, and endangered flora and fauna. Meanwhile, Papohaku Beach Park, known for its scenic beauty, offers picnic tables and camping facilities.

Where to stay on Molokai

Accommodations on Molokai lean towards mid-range options, designed for sustainable tourism practices. Hotel Molokai sits directly on Kamiloloa Beach, providing oceanfront rooms and a peaceful atmosphere. Alternatively, Castle Molokai Shores offers self-catered oceanfront apartments, complete with kitchens and beautiful views.

Best Hawaiian Island: FAQs

As you discover the right Hawaiian island for you, let’s address some frequently asked questions.

What is considered the best Hawaiian island to visit?

Kauai frequently earns the title of the best Hawaiian island due to its stunning natural beauty, earning it the epithet ‘Garden Isle.’

Where should I go for the first time in Hawaii?

For your first visit, the Big Island offers the best variety of activities, including Volcanoes National Park. Oahu is another option, featuring Hawaii’s capital city and the nearby Kona International Airport.

Which Hawaiian island is the most beautiful?

Kauai is often regarded as the island with the most breathtaking scenery, showcasing dramatic cliffs, lush valleys, and stunning hiking trails.

Which is better, Oahu or Maui?

Oahu is ideal for those seeking a bustling atmosphere, while Maui is better for a tranquil and peaceful experience.

Last Word

We hope this guide helps you find the best island to visit in Hawaii. From visiting Pearl Harbor to swimming with Hawaiian green sea turtles or sunbathing on the iconic Waikiki Beach, Hawaii truly has something for everyone. The Hawaiian islands make for an unforgettable holiday destination.

Even after selecting the best island for your visit, consider exploring other Hawaiian islands through day trips. For additional inspiration on where to stay, check out resources that offer valuable accommodation insights.

Plan Your Next Trip to Hawaii With These Resources

• Where to stay in Hawaii: Best Places For You By Island
• 17 Best Hikes in Hawaii You Have to Try Once in Your Life
• The Most Amazing Facts About Hawaii
• 44 Best Things to do on Maui
• Big Island Of Hawaii: 15 Best Things To Do
• The Best Things to do in Oahu, Hawaii

• Facebook
• Twitter

Travel Planning Resources

Looking to plan your next trip? Utilize these resources, which have been tried and tested by travelers.

Flights: Start planning by finding the best flight deals on Skyscanner.

Hotel Deals: For the best hotel prices, check out Booking.com or TripAdvisor.

Apartment Rentals: Discover affordable apartment rentals with VRBO.

Travel Insurance: Ensure you have travel insurance before leaving – here are some reputable options:

• Safety Wing – Ideal for Occasional Travelers.
• Medjet – Global air medical transport and travel security.

Book Activities: For walking tours and skip-the-line tickets, we recommend Get Your Guide.

For more help planning, visit our Resources Page for all the great companies we trust while traveling.