Summary of Brooklyn’s Best Pizza Slices
Brooklyn is renowned for its exceptional pizza, offering everything from artisanal coal oven varieties to traditional neighborhood slices. Numerous noteworthy pizzerias restrict orders to whole pies; however, several standouts provide single slices, enhancing accessibility for pizza lovers. The trend of serving slices is increasingly embraced, with local favorite Paulie Gee’s launching a slice shop soon.
Explore these twelve top pizza slice destinations in Brooklyn:
Table 87
Address: 473 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA
Phone: +1 718-965-8400
The Vibe: This location is the first in Brooklyn to offer coal oven pizza by the slice, targeting those who prefer a casual commitment.
The Slice: Crispy thin crust coal oven pizza featuring house-made mozzarella; the Margherita slice is particularly delicious, though gluten-free options are also available.
The Location: Table 87 boasts three locations across Brooklyn, making it convenient for sightseeing. Frozen pizzas are available from their website and various supermarkets.
The Cost: $4.00 for a plain slice.
Brooklyn Pizza Crew
Address: 758 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA
Phone: +1 718-363-1122
The Vibe: While it resembles a typical Brooklyn pizzeria, vibrant graffiti and modern wooden tables enhance its ambiance.
The Slice: Featuring handcrafted slices, their Sophia Loren lacks sauce but is flavor-packed and fulfilling. There’s also a standout square slice.
The Location: Located in Crown Heights, it’s a brief walk from both the Brooklyn Museum and Brooklyn Botanic Garden.
The Cost: $2.50 for a plain slice and $3.25 for a Sophia Loren.
L & B Spumoni Gardens
Address: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223-3507, USA
Phone: +1 718-449-1230
The Vibe: This authentic Brooklyn locale offers a community feel, perfect for savoring incredible pizza with friends.
The Slice: Renowned for its square slice, each one perfectly balances doughy and cheesy textures. Save space for the spumoni dessert.
The Location: Although not close to Manhattan, it’s ideal for a beach trip to nearby Coney Island; parking can be tricky.
The Cost: $2.75 for a plain slice.
Two Boots
Address: 284 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA
Phone: +1 718-499-0008
The Vibe: Named after the geographical shapes of Italy and Louisiana, this quirky spot caters to families and pizza enthusiasts alike.
The Slice: With whimsical pie names inspired by pop culture, every slice bursts with flavors that reflect their dedication to quality ingredients.
The Location: Although the original Park Slope location closed, the vibrant 5th Avenue spot retains its funky charm; window shopping nearby is a bonus.
The Cost: $2.75 for a cheese slice.
DiFara
Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230-3702, USA
Phone: +1 718-258-1367
The Vibe: A legendary spot in Midwood, this pizzeria has been impressing patrons with fresh slices since the 1960s.
The Slice: With a perfectly crafted thin crust topped with fresh basil, every slice reflects Domenico DeMarco’s mastery over the craft.
The Location: Although slightly off the beaten path, this pizzeria remains a must-visit destination for pizza lovers willing to make the pilgrimage.
The Cost: $5 for a slice of pizza.
Best Pizza Williamsburg
The Vibe: Situated in a former bakery, this homey pizzeria features walls adorned with creatively designed paper plates from customers.
The Slice: Made in a century-old oven, the pizza is topped with a signature single basil leaf, and locals particularly favor the white pizza.
The Location: Nestled in Williamsburg, it’s ideal after shopping on Bedford Avenue or enjoying a scenic leisure walk at East River State Park.
The Cost: $3.25 for a plain slice.
Front Street Pizza
Address: 80 Front St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA
Phone: +1 718-875-3700
The Vibe: A casual spot that’s a local favorite, especially ideal for budget-conscious diners looking for flavorful options.
The Slice: Offering classic pizzeria options, their fresh thin crust pizza is a crowd-pleaser, and gluten-free selections are also available.
The Location: Perfectly positioned near Grimaldi’s, it offers a quick slice option for visitors in Dumbo.
The Cost: $2.75 for a plain slice.
Screamer’s Pizzeria
Address: 620 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222-3923, USA
Phone: +1 347-844-9412
The Vibe: This vegan pizzeria attracts plant-based enthusiasts seeking fresh, delicious pizza with limited seating.
The Slice: The tremendous flavors may lead you to believe you’re enjoying traditional cheese, which showcases the innovation behind vegan alternatives.
The Location: Located on bustling Manhattan Avenue, it’s also conveniently near other local shops worth exploring.
The Cost: $3 for a plain slice.
Pizza Wagon
Address: 8610 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209-5202, USA
Phone: +1 718-836-5725
The Vibe: With an inviting 80’s décor, it evokes nostalgia while still delivering fresh, delicious food in Bay Ridge.
The Slice: Their pizza offers an ideal balance of cheese, sauce, and crispy dough; be sure to try both the regular and square slices.
The Location: Conveniently located near various local shops and attractions, it’s easy to pop in for a quick satisfying meal.
The Cost: $2.50 for a plain slice.
Layla Jones
Address: 214 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201-6405, USA
Phone: +1 718-624-2361
The Vibe: Family-run in Cobble Hill, this restaurant offers a spacious backyard ideal for enjoyable dining when the weather cooperates.
The Slice: A delightful square slice, characterized by its fresh, light crust and sweet sauce; pepperoni and mushroom options are also available.
The Location: Conveniently located near the F train at Bergen Street, making it easy to explore and enjoy the vibrant neighborhood.
The Cost: $2.50 for a plain Jane slice.
House of Pizza and Calzone
Address: 132 Union St, Brooklyn, NY 11231-2983, USA
Phone: +1 718-624-9107
The Vibe: A beloved neighborhood establishment that has served the community for over 60 years, known for its welcoming atmosphere.
The Slice: Their aromatic peppery slice is well-loved, featuring fresh ingredients; deep-fried calzones also get rave reviews.
The Location: Located in Carroll Gardens, the vicinity boasts various Italian eateries and prolific pizza options, making it an excellent choice for authentic taste.
The Cost: $3 for a plain slice.
Antonio’s Pizzeria
The Vibe: This classic pizzeria retains the charm of old-school Brooklyn, delivering fresh slices to patrons for over fifty years.
The Slice: The simple yet well-layered plain slice allows for a delightful New York experience; options for various toppings are available.
The Location: Found on Flatbush Avenue, Antonio’s is just steps from Prospect Park and conveniently near Park Slope’s 7th Avenue, making it a perfect pitstop.
The Cost: $2.75 for a plain slice, with a special two-slice and soda combo for $6.
