Top 10 Must-Try Iconic Brooklyn Dishes

Brooklyn is a culinary destination. Home to the original Smorgasburg that spread to LA and Michelin star restaurants; this part of New York City is a haven for foodies. New restaurants are sprouting up across the borough; however, before you embark on a tour of all the trendy new spots in Brooklyn, dining on the foods that made Brooklyn famous is essential. From a decadent meal at a classic steakhouse to a legendary square slice at an old-school pizzeria, you won’t be disappointed devouring these ten iconic Brooklyn dishes.

Junior’s Cheesecake at Junior’s Restaurant

Since 1950, folks have been flocking to Junior’s Restaurant for a slice of their famed cheesecake. Choose from over a dozen varieties, including devil’s food, strawberry, apple crumb, or stick with a slice of plain cheesecake. Junior’s cheesecake is one of Brooklyn’s most famous desserts, and once you take a bite, you’ll understand why they are a favorite. Additionally, if you’re also on the hunt for authentic Brooklyn deli food, this is the spot to satiate your craving. The menu is filled with classics including matzoh ball soup, chopped liver, brisket, blintzes, and a selection of sandwiches. Don’t forget to save room for the cheesecake.

Egg Cream at The Brooklyn Farmacy

Did you know there aren’t any eggs in an egg cream? This classic drink contains seltzer, milk, and chocolate syrup. For decades, Brooklyn was known for its classic egg cream, traditionally found at local soda fountains or pharmacies. As these establishments closed, the egg cream almost became extinct. Fortunately, it has been reborn at the Brooklyn Farmacy, a family-owned soda fountain where you can sip egg creams and malts at the counter. Located in a restored 1920s corner pharmacy in Carroll Gardens, this charming ice cream parlor also serves comfort food.

Square Slice at L & B Spumoni Gardens

For years, folks have traveled to this beloved Bensonhurst pizzeria for a square slice. This cozy spot evokes feelings of authentic Brooklyn, where locals hang out on red picnic benches chatting as they devour some of the best pizza in the borough. While it may be a long haul from Manhattan and brownstone Brooklyn, it’s worth the journey. An added bonus is its proximity to Coney Island for those who wish to combine a visit with a trip to the beach. Just remember to leave room for spumoni at this Brooklyn staple.

Rainbow Bagel at The Bagel Store

When Scot Rossilo (owner of the Williamsburg Bagel Store) introduced the rainbow bagel in early 2016, it quickly became an instant sensation. After being featured on ESPN during the Super Bowl and on Late Show with Steve Colbert, where Broad City’s Abbi Jacobson and Ilana Glazer presented the host with the bagel, lines began forming outside the store. The demand was so intense that it necessitated a temporary closure of the Bedford Avenue location. A year later, the rainbow bagel has become a Brooklyn staple at The Bagel Store and many other bagel shops throughout the borough. Experience the authentic rainbow bagel at the Bagel Store on Bedford Avenue or at their Metropolitan Avenue location. Although lines can still be long, they are not as intense as before. In addition to the rainbow bagel, make sure to try Scot Rossilo’s other inventive creations, including the bacon, egg and cheese bagel and the cragel.

Steak from Peter Luger

Meat lovers must indulge in a steak dinner at the famous Peter Luger Steakhouse in Williamsburg. This historic eatery has been serving customers since 1897 and has a rich legacy. Recognized as one of NYC’s top-rated steakhouses, Peter Luger showcases a timeless ambiance with its wood-paneled walls and bar. Customers can enjoy sharing a steak platter after ordering a refreshment from the bar. Making reservations is advisable due to the high demand from hungry patrons. It’s worth noting that Peter Luger doesn’t accept credit cards, but they do accept debit cards.

Hot Dog at Nathan’s

You can’t visit Brooklyn without stopping by Coney Island, and a trip there isn’t complete without ordering a classic hot dog from Nathan’s. This iconic shop, open for over a hundred years, offers an experience that their chain locations can never replicate. Standing in line and inhaling the salty beach air heightens the anticipation. Pair your hot dog with a side of cheese fries for a delightful pre-beach meal. Moreover, Nathan’s remains open year-round, making it an ideal destination even outside summer. After enjoying an original hot dog where it all began, take a stroll down the boardwalk past the famous Parachute Jump, and if the weather allows, try the Wonder Wheel. Don’t forget to visit Nathan’s on July 4th to catch their annual hot dog eating contest.

Roll-n-Roaster Beef Sandwich at Roll-n-Roaster

For a satisfying roast beef sandwich, Brooklyn locals will direct you to Roll-n-Roaster, located in Sheepshead Bay. Even if roast beef isn’t your preference, this nostalgic fast-food restaurant is a must-visit. Enjoy a slice of pizza while washing it down with refreshing lemonade. If it happens to be your birthday, they let you spin a wheel similar to the one on Wheel of Fortune for a chance at free food. With retro orange and yellow decor, Roll-n-Roaster captures a piece of the 70s ambiance. After your meal, don’t miss the opportunity to stroll over the scenic footbridge nearby.

Dim Sum at Pacificana

While numerous Chinese restaurants are located in Sunset Park, a dim sum lunch at Pacificana stands out as a beloved Brooklyn tradition. This spacious second-floor banquet-style restaurant is popular among diners, so be prepared for a wait or arrive before 11 AM. The atmospheric venue features a menu replete with traditional dim sum selections, with soup dumplings boasting local fame. Grab sticky rice from a cart and choose from a variety of dim sum staples. It’s an excellent way to kickstart your day. If you prefer a late start, consider returning for Cantonese family-style cuisine featuring favorites like Chicken Chow Mein, Egg Rolls, and Fried Rice.

Pizza at Di Fara

At Di Fara Pizzeria, the wait becomes worthwhile as you observe Domenico DeMarco crafting your pie. This Midwood pizzeria is legendary, often drawing visitors from afar for a taste of its acclaimed pizza. While the process may require patience, witnessing the artistry behind each pie makes the experience even more rewarding. Unlike the newer pizza establishments emerging around Brooklyn, Di Fara maintains an old-school storefront aesthetic. To minimize your wait, consider visiting at an off-peak hour.

Tatiana’s Russian Banquet

The “Russian Style” banquet at Tatiana in Brighton Beach offers a feast of appetizers, salads, beef stew, lamb, and a multitude of desserts. Opting for a standard banquet or going for an upscale experience includes not just incredible cuisine but also a lively floor show that would rival any entertainment from Vegas or cruise ships. While à la carte dining is available, the true allure lies in the banquet package on weekends, which features upbeat entertainment along with a diverse assortment of dishes. Enjoy a family-style feast while watching costumed dancers. For those unable to attend on the weekend, soak in the scenery by dining at the seaside restaurant and relish the ocean breeze afterward.