1. Introduction
If you’re heading to Hawaii, you’ll find gorgeous beaches, an abundance of hiking trails, fresh food, and opportunities to learn about culture and history, no matter which island you choose.
However, each island has its own distinct personality. Therefore, picking just one can be a challenge. If you’re trying to decide between Maui and Kauai, this guide is designed to help you determine which island best suits your travel style, beyond the obvious sand, surf, and sun (and yes, plenty of mai tais) you’ll find throughout the state.
2. How to Travel to Maui and Kauai
Unless you’re a highly experienced sailor or planning to take a transpacific cruise, the only way to reach Hawaii’s remote archipelago from the continental U.S. is via airplane. According to Hawaii Visitors and Convention Bureau’s analysis of Diio Mi air data, there are currently more than 120 direct flights each week to Lihue, Kauai, from a number of cities in the continental U.S., including Phoenix, Denver, Seattle, and Los Angeles, as well as four direct flights per week from Vancouver, Canada. You’ll have even more options if you’re heading to Maui: 316 direct flights travel each week from the continental U.S. to Kahului, Maui, and another 35 direct flights depart from Calgary, Edmonton, Toronto, and Vancouver, Canada.
3. Experiences on Maui and Kauai
A trip to any Hawaiian island is bound to be memorable; however, some of the extra-special experiences and incredible views are unique to each destination.
On Maui, sit above the clouds and watch the sunrise at 10,000 feet atop Haleakalā, a sacred site and dormant volcano that covers more than 75 percent of the island and is home to over 100 endangered species, including Hawaii’s state bird, the nene. You’ll start the journey up the steep and winding road in the early hours, but it’s well worth the early alarm. If you’d rather not drive yourself, consider booking a small group tour.
If you’re a hiker, Kauai offers a plethora of trails to explore. One must-visit is Waimea Canyon State Park, known as the “Grand Canyon of the Pacific,” where you can see colorful views and unique geological formations.
4. Weather on Maui and Kauai
In general, Hawaii has two seasons: summer (May to October) and winter (November to April). Daytime temperatures average around 85 degrees Fahrenheit in the summer and around 78 degrees in the winter. The islands receive more rain in winter months, which can impact visibility and views at popular locations.
Kauai is considered one of the rainiest places on the planet, contributing to its lush landscape. While sunny days can often be found on the southern side, rain isn’t guaranteed.
Maui tends to receive less rainfall than Kauai, with its leeward side generally being drier.
5. Water Activities on Maui and Kauai
Maui’s beaches are arguably more accessible than Kauai’s, offering calmer waters. Both islands provide ample opportunities for ocean activities such as surfing, snorkeling, diving, and outrigger canoe paddling.
Kauai is unique in Hawaii for its navigable rivers, making it the ideal location for river kayaking.
Maui is home to Molokini, a partially submerged volcanic crater known for its snorkeling and diving experiences due to the calm and clear waters.
6. Cultural Experiences on Maui and Kauai
Both islands offer various ways to immerse yourself in Hawaiian culture, with each presenting unique opportunities.
Learn about caring for the land by volunteering with Maui Cultural Lands in a Saturday volunteer experience.
On Kauai, the southern coast features the Koloa Heritage Trail, a 10-mile tour that showcases cultural, geological, and historical sites.
7. Nightlife on Maui and Kauai
Kauai tends to have a quieter nightlife, ideal for families and those seeking relaxation. However, for a more lively atmosphere, there are several options in more populated areas.
On Maui, the nightlife is more vibrant and eclectic, with options ranging from happy hour to live music and dance parties.
8. Day Trips From Maui and Kauai
Even if you choose to stay on one island, a mini multi-island adventure is easily achievable. From Maui, consider a ferry to Lanai to explore its tranquil offerings. From Kauai, excursions near Niihau provide snorkel opportunities alongside stunning coastal views.
