We frequently encounter the question: Nantucket or Martha’s Vineyard?
While visiting both islands is certainly an option—given that both are cherished getaways accessible by ferry and have airports—summer vacation time is often limited. Therefore, this question deserves a thoughtful answer.
Associate Editor Ann Douglas Lott champions the hilly landscapes and charming towns on Martha’s Vineyard. On the other hand, Senior Director of Content Brekke Fletcher, despite a chilly and rain-soaked trip to Nantucket, maintains a strong preference for the latter.
Even though these two contributors work closely together, this debate is one that had to happen. It’s now up to you to decide which writer makes the more compelling case for their favored summer isle. Let the comparisons begin!
Why Martha’s Vineyard is Summertime Bliss
With rugged, hilly terrains, breathtaking ocean cliffs, and over 120 miles of pristine coastlines, Martha’s Vineyard undeniably stands out as a summertime paradise. Both Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard feature beautiful beaches, fresh seafood, and picturesque, walkable towns. However, when it comes to natural beauty and diverse experiences, Martha’s Vineyard (or, as locals call it, the Vineyard) is unparalleled.
Getting to Martha’s Vineyard is generally easier, with numerous ferry services available, particularly during the high season. Ferries regularly operate from New Bedford and Cape Cod, as well as from nearby states like Rhode Island and New York. Furthermore, the island has an airport, making direct flights accessible from major cities more affordable.
Upon arrival at Oak Bluffs, you can explore its lively town filled with colorful “gingerbread houses,” and enjoy local attractions such as the carousel and delightful ice cream shops. Whether you rent a car or utilize reliable public transportation, Martha’s Vineyard offers ample opportunities for exploration.
For a fulfilling experience, consider spending several days on the island. Martha’s Vineyard consists of six distinctive towns: Aquinnah, Chilmark, Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, Vineyard Haven, and West Tisbury. Each town offers a unique atmosphere — from traditional, charming brick lanes in Edgartown to the tranquil vibe of Aquinnah with its stunning cliffs.
The array of beaches, including Aquinnah Beach famous for its dramatic waves and serene sunsets, and Lighthouse Beach in Edgartown celebrated for its calmer waters, ensures you won’t run out of spots to relax and unwind. Moreover, the vibrant environment at South Beach, known from the iconic film Jaws, adds another dimension to your beach day.
Martha’s Vineyard maintains a rugged charm, allowing you to connect with nature—whether you’re enjoying a peaceful sunset on a secluded beach or hiking along scenic cliffs. Almost one-third of the island remains protected, ensuring a lack of commercial exploitation and preserving its local character. You won’t encounter strict dress codes here, allowing for a truly laid-back experience.
If you’re contemplating a visit to both islands, consider Nantucket for a day trip to savor its unique offerings without compromising on the Vineyard experience. Return in time to enjoy another spectacular sunset.
Nantucket’s Beaches Are for Everyone
The sunsets on Nantucket are equally captivating. While it may be smaller and flatter than Martha’s Vineyard, this distinctiveness offers an advantage: easier navigation, especially by bicycle. Consequently, Nantucket is an excellent choice for those seeking an eco-friendly vacation.
Nantucket provides a charming coastal village atmosphere with shingled buildings and historic sea captain’s homes lining its brick-paved streets. Its quaint downtown center is exceptionally walkable, teeming with extraordinary dining options and unique shopping experiences.
Unlike Martha’s Vineyard, where some areas can feel exclusive, all of Nantucket’s beaches are open to the public, ensuring that everyone can enjoy the sun and surf without restrictions.
Nantucket’s beaches cater to diverse preferences, whether you seek the family-friendly atmosphere of Jetties Beach or quieter northern shores like “The Bathtub.” Each beach presents a unique allure, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
In addition to the stunning coastlines, Nantucket hosts a variety of accommodations, ranging from charming B&Bs to upscale hotels — all devoid of the crowded resort vibe found elsewhere. The island’s farmers’ markets and local provisions provide fresh, high-quality products, making it a culinary delight.
Although both islands offer unique attractions, Nantucket shines in its serene charm that remains invigorating beyond the summer season. Visiting late September allows you to relish in the final warmth of summer before the island transitions into a picturesque autumn.
