Discover 20 Unforgettable Hidden Gems in New Jersey

New Jersey, often referred to as the Garden State, is widely known for attractions such as the Jersey Shore and Atlantic City. However, the state offers a vast array of experiences for visitors, including family-friendly venues and picturesque drives that will captivate those who venture beyond metropolitan areas. Prepare to embark on a journey to discover both the countryside and coastal marvels, including historic parks and structures, and possibly even a colossal elephant. Numerous delightful eateries await your visit during this exploration!

Here is a curated selection of New Jersey’s best-hidden gems!

1. Diggerland, USA, West Berlin

Diggerland presents a distinctive amusement park experience, serving as the only construction-themed park in the United States, filled with innovative rides. Rather than the typical bumper cars, here you can operate construction vehicles for a unique perspective on amusement parks.

Experience a thrilling ride on the Spin Dizzy, a 20-ton excavator adapted to transport guests. If you are visiting West Berlin in October, consider attending “Diggerfest,” a festival tailored for families. Enjoy hay rides, navigate mazes, or witness stunt performances. After visiting this hidden treasure, standard amusement parks may not suffice!

2. Old Mine Road

Old Mine Road is one of the oldest continuously used roads in the United States, traversing both New Jersey and New York. It spans 104 miles, connecting the Delaware Water Gap Recreation Area to Kingston, New York. While modernized in New York, much of the route in New Jersey remains pristine, preserving the Dutch architecture and historic sites from the original settlers.

Embark on a drive along the road between the Delaware Water Gap and Port Jervis. You can extend your journey with a camping stop at Worthington State Forest, enjoying charming two-lane roads while retracing the heritage of early Dutch American colonial history at this historical treasure.

3. The Crab Shack

With a long Atlantic coastline, New Jersey is home to exceptional seafood offerings. Dining at local favorites, particularly by the beach, adds to the experience. The outdoor setting alongside the ocean enhances the flavor of the seafood.

Visit the Crab Shack in Brick for delectable seafood options. Sample a tuna burger or coconut shrimp, or opt for clam chowder if you prefer traditional dishes. Regardless of your preference, the Crab Shack guarantees satisfaction.

4. Yankee Doodle Tap Room

While in Princeton, a visit to the historic Nassau Inn is warranted, particularly for a drink at the Yankee Doodle Tap Room. Established in 1756, this tavern upholds English pub traditions and is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Choose from 19 beers on tap, featuring a mix of craft selections and classic pub fare. Be sure to take note of the large Norman Rockwell mural, a notable highlight of the venue. Relax in the sturdy oak booths and, should the opportunity arise, enjoy live music while savoring excellent food and drinks in this inviting space.

5. Rutgers Garden

Situated between the Turnpike and Route 1, Rutgers Garden is a lesser-known gem even among local residents. If you are in New Brunswick, take a moment to stretch your legs at the university’s botanical garden.

Home to the second largest collection of holly in the United States, Rutgers Garden offers visitors the chance to explore its beautiful grounds, complemented by a weekly farmers market featuring produce sourced directly from the gardens. This delightful retreat from hustle and bustle is well worth a visit.

6. Asbury Park Pedal Boats, Wesley Lake

Wesley Lake lies between Asbury Park and Ocean Grove. In the 1960s, it hosted a popular attraction in the form of a large, motorized Swan Boat, which eventually vanished until the revival of swan paddle boats.

Although smaller than its predecessor, these paddle boats provide a delightful family outing. Enjoy a leisurely afternoon gliding across the water, cherishing the opportunity to create new memories while reflecting on fond experiences from the past.

7. The Brewer’s Apprentice, Freehold

For those who appreciate beer, The Brewer’s Apprentice in Freehold is an ideal destination. This location offers a diverse array of activities, including the opportunity to craft your own beer, wine, or even mead, while customizable soda options cater to non-alcohol drinkers.

Dedicate a few hours to engage in the user-friendly processes available. Discover the nuances of beverage creation or simply enjoy sampling their selections on tap. This locale also provides private event options, making it an excellent choice for gatherings. Regardless of your visit duration, ensure responsible enjoyment at this lively brewery, where you can evolve from novice to adept beer taster.

8. Lucy the Elephant, Atlantic City

Lucy is a six-story building in the shape of an elephant, designed by James Lafferty in 1881. This historic roadside attraction is the oldest of its kind still standing in the United States. Originally intended to promote real estate sales, Lucy now welcomes visitors in Atlantic City.

When in the area, consider climbing the spiral staircase hidden within Lucy. If you’re adventurous enough to reach the top, you’re rewarded with breathtaking views (don’t overlook the water tower emblazoned with a smiley face!). Capture photographs of the skyline and your visit with the grand elephant.

9. Gardner’s Basin, Atlantic City

While Atlantic City is often synonymous with gambling and the Boardwalk, Gardner’s Basin offers a hidden treasure for visitors willing to explore beyond traditional attractions. Once a hub for rum-running activities, this area now features a vibrant marine ecosystem, delightful residences, restaurants, and diverse entertainment options.

Discover the historical facets of Atlantic City and be sure to visit the aquarium, which houses over 100 species of fish. Consider booking a fishing or boating excursion followed by a relaxing meal at Back Bay Ale House. This experience will create unique memories of Atlantic City, providing a refreshing alternative to the renowned casinos.

10. Deep Cut Gardens, Middletown

Spanning over 50 acres in Middletown, Deep Cut Gardens is an essential stop for horticultural enthusiasts and home gardeners. Engage with knowledgeable staff at the horticultural center for tailored advice and recommendations on your visit or personal gardening projects.

Experience over 50 varieties of rose bushes and native plant species cultivated for your enjoyment. Take advantage of the on-site library and participate in various events and classes offered throughout the year. This oasis of greenery is well worth your visit.

11. Papa’s Tomato Pies, Robbinsville

Papa’s Tomato Pies is renowned as the oldest family-owned pizza establishment in the United States, having been founded in 1912. Its authenticity and charm have captured the attention of many, including culinary media.

Indulge in any of their renowned pies, still crafted by descendants of the original owner, Giuseppe Papa, who hailed from Naples. The family has preserved the original recipes across multiple generations, ensuring an unparalleled dining experience that nurtures both your hunger and soul.

12. Valley Shepherd Creamery, Long Valley

For a serene escape from the urban environment, Valley Shepherd Creamery in Long Valley offers a charming getaway over 100 acres. Revel in artisanal cheese tastings crafted from sheep reared via traditional European techniques, ensuring an authentic dairy experience.

The knowledgeable staff provides insights into their cheese-making processes, with over 30 varieties available, including cheese, butter, and yogurt. This locale is a delightful haven for dairy enthusiasts, making sampling their offerings a must.

13. Grover’s Mill Coffee House, West Windsor

This café, renowned for its excellent coffee, also hosts a unique aspect of New Jersey’s history. Located in West Windsor, Grover’s Mill Coffee House features intriguing artwork that recounts a radio drama that duped many into believing an alien invasion had occurred in Grover’s Mill.

Savor a classic cup of coffee or opt for a nitro brew while taking in the creative artwork that interprets this fictional extraterrestrial event. This unique ambiance invites reflection while enjoying delightful beverages and light fare.

14. The Stickley Museum, Morris Plains

Situated on a 30-acre estate, The Stickley Museum showcases the legacy of Gustav Stickley, an early proponent of the Arts and Crafts movement in America. This expansive complex represents his commitment to design that emphasizes simplicity and quality, diverging from Victorian styles.

Visitors can gain insight into the life of a innovator dedicated to improving the working class’s conditions through his designs. The museum provides a refreshing perspective on furniture making and home decor design, imparting a sense of connection to a bygone era.

15. Greenwood Gardens, Short Hills

Originally a 76-acre property acquired by Joseph Day in 1906, Greenwood Gardens includes meticulously designed gardens that were revitalized in 1944 by new owner Peter Blanchard. The transformation revitalized the grounds, which now captivate visitors with their lush beauty.

While an admission fee applies, the experience is worthwhile, with features appealing to both art and horticulture aficionados. Don’t miss the wrought iron gate by Samuel Yellin or the bronze statue by Emilio Angela, both of which infuse charm into the extensive estate. Check the event schedule to partake in educational and cultural programs to enhance your visit.

16. Green Sergeant’s Covered Bridge

New Jersey once featured over 75 covered bridges, with Green Sergeant’s Covered Bridge standing among the few that remain. Constructed in 1872 and reconstructed in 1960 using authentic materials, this bridge is a must-see while traversing the Garden State.

Be sure to stop for a moment to admire this historic structure surrounded by beautiful nature. Capture some photographs to memorialize your visit and appreciate the quaint charm of these rare remnants from a time when life moved more slowly.

17. Franklin Mineral Museum, Franklin

Situated in Sussex County, the Franklin Mineral Museum offers visitors a unique experience at the location of the former Franklin Mine. This mine was active until the 1950s and subsequently transformed into an open-air museum in 1964.

Discover the captivating world of minerals, geology, and mining through exhibits that include a simulated mine tunnel and Native American artifacts. Visitors can explore the mine replica and fluorescent mineral rooms, making it an unforgettable experience for history, geology, and nature enthusiasts.

18. Sunset Beach, Cape May

During your visit to New Jersey, take advantage of the coastal scenery at Sunset Beach in Cape May. This secluded beach offers a romantic ambiance to witness the sunset, consistent with its name.

Arrive with ample daylight to investigate a sunken World War I vessel that has remained stuck in a sandbar over the years. The Atlantus now coexists with the beach as nature has gradually reclaimed her. Stroll along the shoreline collecting quartz rocks and creating beautiful memories of your time spent in this idyllic locale.

19. Cowtown Rodeo

Nestled in Pilesgrove and Woodstown lies the longest-running weekly rodeo in the United States. Established in 1929, it has entertained generations and remains a thrilling option for those searching for Western-themed excitement.

Locals, including Grant Harris’ family, have provided this captivating experience much closer to home. Witness extraordinary cowboys and cowgirls competing in events spanning two hours each week, immersing yourself in a slice of the Wild West.

20. Buttermilk Falls State Park

Located in the northern region of New Jersey, Buttermilk Falls is a remarkable natural site, recognized as the tallest waterfall in the state and an excellent area for hiking and birdwatching. Prepare your hiking boots for an outdoor adventure amidst nature.

Ascend to the falls to capture photographs while enjoying the avian wildlife. For those seeking a challenge, continue your hike to explore Hemlock Pond or Crater Lake. The route to Buttermilk Falls is easily accessible from the parking lot; however, additional trails lead to the lesser-known Hidden Falls, providing a chance to escape city life and delve into nature.