The Best Diners in New Jersey

If you’ve ever visited New Jersey, there’s a strong chance you’ve experienced the joy of dining in a classic diner. These establishments are a melting pot of culture, showcasing everything from teens enjoying late-night milkshakes to longstanding friends relishing their favorite soups. With over 500 diners, New Jersey proudly holds the title of the “Diner Capital of the World.”

The History of Diners in New Jersey

The concept of diners originated in 1872 in Providence, Rhode Island, when businessman Walter Scott began selling meals from a horse-drawn wagon. This innovative idea quickly spread throughout New England. In New Jersey, pioneers like Jerry O’Mahony established diner manufacturing companies, constructing permanent diners from railway cars to serve the bustling working-class population.

Throughout the 20th century, diners blossomed across New Jersey, evolving into roadside jewels known for their unique aesthetics, particularly the neon-lit designs popularized in the post-war era. Today, while not every diner retains this classic style, they continue to thrive by offering extensive menus that range from all-day breakfast to Greek specialties and homemade desserts.

Those in search of iconic local dishes like pork rolls (Taylor ham) and disco fries will find diners to be some of the best places to indulge. However, choosing the best diners can be subjective; many New Jerseyans have deep-rooted loyalties to their favorite spots. Here, we present a curated selection of restaurants that stand out for their historical significance and popularity.

1. Summit Diner – Summit

Best diner for nostalgia

Opened in 1928, the Summit Diner is the oldest operating diner in New Jersey. Its building, constructed in 1939, reflects the classic train-car style. Local folklore suggests that Ernest Hemingway dined here, underscoring its authenticity and charm. Be sure to try the sliders, a unique take featuring mini Taylor ham, egg, and cheese sandwiches.

2. Jefferson Diner – Lake Hopatcong

Best diner for giant portions

Established in 1985, the Jefferson Diner showcases a retro aesthetic complete with neon lights and chrome finishes. It has gained recognition, appearing on Guy Fieri’s “Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives.” The diner’s owners even acquired Fieri’s classic car, adding to its allure.

3. Skylark Fine Diner and Lounge – Edison

Best diner for breakfast

Open since 2006, Skylark offers a modern take on traditional dining. Its diverse menu includes classic American breakfasts and international dishes in a contemporary setting, appealing to a new generation of diner enthusiasts.

4. Broad Street Diner – Keyport

Best diner for a good cup of coffee

Another Jerry O’Mahony creation, the Broad Street Diner has remained a local favorite for over 70 years. Known for its chocolate babka French toast and high-quality coffee from a private roaster, this diner successfully blends nostalgia with quality.

5. George’s Place – Cape May

Best diner for Greek specialties

Founded in 1968, George’s Place features a Greek-inspired menu with highlights like gyros and falafel. Its casual yet sophisticated atmosphere sets it apart from typical diners, making it a delightful stop along the beach.

6. Mustache Bill’s – Barnegat Light

Best diner for pancakes

Mustache Bill’s, a seasonal gem founded in 1972, is celebrated for its homemade dishes. The diner’s remarkable pancakes, particularly “The Cyclops” with an egg in the center, have earned it accolades from local foodies and the James Beard Foundation.

7. Tick Tock Diner – Clifton

Best diner for late-night munchies

Open 24/7, the Tick Tock Diner caters to night owls craving a delicious meal anytime. After a major renovation in 2019, it combines classic diner aesthetics with modern touches. Renowned for its Taylor ham, egg, and cheese sandwiches, as well as disco fries, it attracts a diverse clientele, including celebrities.

8. Tops Diner – East Newark

Best diner for classic diner grub

The Tops Diner, initially opened in 1942, recently underwent a significant renovation. While some debate its new aesthetics, this diner remains popular for its extensive menu, which includes beloved items like lobster mac and cheese.