Underrated Theater Cities in America

New York City may be the theater capital of America, but smaller theater scenes around the United States also shine brightly. The productions in these ten underrated towns are worth experiencing and showcase the vibrant arts culture that thrives beyond Broadway.

1. Minneapolis

Sir Tyrone Guthrie moved to Minneapolis to establish his own repertory company in 1963, leading to the creation of the esteemed Guthrie Theater. This venue has gained recognition for presenting both classic and contemporary works, making it one of the most acclaimed theaters in the Twin Cities. In fact, Minneapolis and neighboring St. Paul boast nearly 200 theaters, including notable organizations like Brave New Workshop Theatre and the Children’s Theater Company. Visitors to the area can enjoy a wealth of performances and artistic endeavors that enhance the cultural fabric of this vibrant city.

2. Chicago

With its rich theater culture, Chicago rivals any major city. The scene flourished in the mid-20th century thanks to groups like Second City and Steppenwolf Theatre. These companies set the stage for a vibrant array of storefront theaters run by passionate post-graduates eager to showcase intimate productions. Moreover, The Loop’s historic Broadway-style houses offer big-budget musicals, while acclaimed companies like Goodman and Lookingglass Theatre continue to push the boundaries of creativity.

3. Washington, DC

The theater scene in Washington, DC offers diverse productions that appeal to a wide audience. The Kennedy Center serves as a hub for touring shows and concerts, while venues like Wooly Mammoth Theatre provide innovative and experimental performances. Signature Theater and Shakespeare Theatre Company contribute to the rich theater culture, showcasing groundbreaking adaptations and ambitious productions.

4. Philadelphia

Philadelphia is a treasure trove for history enthusiasts and theater lovers alike. Home to the Walnut Street Theatre, the oldest continually operating playhouse in America, the city is renowned for its dynamic storytelling. In addition to blockbuster Broadway shows at the Kimmel Center and Academy of Music, locals enjoy performances from a myriad of smaller organizations offering fresh and innovative narratives.

5. San Diego

San Diego’s theater scene thrives with creative energy, exemplified by La Jolla Playhouse and The Old Globe, both of which have launched numerous successful productions on Broadway. The city boasts nearly 150 active performance spaces, enabling it to be celebrated as a “Broadway by the beach.” This vibrant cultural ecosystem attracts artists and audiences alike, providing a rich theater experience.

6. Louisville

Louisville becomes a hotspot for artistic innovation during the annual Humana Festival at the Actors Theatre of Louisville. Celebrated worldwide, this festival acts as a platform for fresh theatrical works and emerging playwrights, garnering critical acclaim and capturing the passion of theater enthusiasts.

7. Seattle

Seattle’s theater scene, despite its often gray weather, showcases remarkable talent and creativity. A Contemporary Theater and Seattle Rep consistently deliver evocative performances, while the 5th Avenue Theatre nurtures new musicals, contributing to the region’s theatrical legacy. The Paramount, Moore, and Neptune Theaters offer a wide range of live events throughout the year.

8. Boston

Boston stands out as an educational hub for upcoming talents in theater. With prestigious regional theaters like Huntington Theatre Company and American Repertory Theater closely affiliated with local universities, the city fosters a vibrant atmosphere for artistic exploration and innovation. The proximity to surrounding areas hosting additional arts events further enriches Boston’s theatrical offerings.

9. Denver

Despite its reputation for outdoor adventures, Denver houses the impressive Denver Center for the Performing Arts, the largest non-profit theater organization in the nation. This venue hosts not only national tour premiers but also produces its own world-class performances, showcasing the flourishing artistic community within the Mile High City.

10. Dallas/Fort Worth

Texas is known for its larger-than-life culture, and the theater scene in Dallas/Fort Worth is no exception. The AT&T Performing Arts Center features glitzy productions, while smaller companies like Uptown Players and Theatre Three deliver unique and quirky performances. With various theater initiatives, Dallas Theater Center has played a vital role in shaping the theatrical landscape through innovative productions and classic reimaginations.