Who Makes the Best Juicy Lucy Burger in Minneapolis?

The Juicy Lucy, also known as Juicy Lucy burger, is a beloved culinary invention from Minneapolis. This unique cheeseburger features melted cheese inside the meat patty, creating a molten cheese center that is both thrilling and cautionary, as diners must beware of scalding cheese upon the first bite.

Originating in the 1950s from a south Minneapolis bar, the Juicy Lucy burger is claimed by two prominent establishments: the 5-8 Club, known for its “Juicy Lucy,” and Matt’s Bar, which serves the “Jucy Lucy,” famously stating that “if it’s spelled correctly, you’re at the wrong place.” Ultimately, the debate of who invented it first may never be settled, but the real question remains: who makes it best?

Matt’s Bar and the Jucy Lucy

Address: 3500 Cedar Ave, Minneapolis, MN 55407, USA

Phone: +1 612-722-7072

Website: Visit website

Matt’s Bar proudly claims to serve the original Jucy Lucy, and although the exact genesis remains murky, the dining experience here is unmistakably classic. With minimal changes since the 1950s, the hamburgers are grilled right behind the bar, resulting in a unique blend of crispy exterior and tender interior filled with melted cheese.

This burger is a comforting choice with its cheesy flavor, fatty richness, and value-priced beers. Visitors typically receive their orders promptly, alongside a caution about the molten cheese, and can enjoy their burgers with a refreshing pint of Grain Belt.

While the dive bar ambiance may deter some, the Jucy Lucy from Matt’s Bar is a must-try and arguably the best in the city, despite the 5-8 Club offering superior bun quality for their burgers.

The 5-8 Club and the Juicy Lucy Burger

Address: 5800 Cedar Ave, Minneapolis, MN 55417, USA

Phone: +1 612-823-5858

Website: Visit website

The 5-8 Club takes a more assertive stance in claiming the original Juicy Lucy title compared to the laid-back approach of Matt’s Bar. At the 5-8 Club, their Juicy Lucy is crafted with American cheese and served on freshly baked buns, which are a notable improvement over the offerings at Matt’s Bar. Their burgers tend to retain more heated cheese, creating bursts of flavor with each bite.

However, the flavor profile of the meat at 5-8 does not quite reach the heights of Matt’s burger. Modern renovations have shifted the bar’s character, moving away from the speakeasy vibe that once defined it, resulting in a more family-friendly establishment that caters to a diverse clientele.

Despite being in a different league than Matt’s, the 5-8 Club’s Juicy Lucy maintains a formidable reputation and remains a culinary symbol of Minneapolis.

The Nook Bar, St. Paul, and the Nookie Burger

Address: 492 Hamline Ave S, St Paul, MN 55116, USA

Phone: +1 651-698-4347

Website: Visit website

New contenders in St. Paul are emerging to challenge the classic Minneapolis burger joints. Notably, The Nook Bar has created its own version of the Juicy Lucy, dubbed the Nookie Burger. This modest sports bar is renowned locally, with awards highlighting its exceptional burger offerings. Consequently, the Nookie Burger stands shoulder to shoulder with Minneapolis staples and is certainly worth the drive across the Mississippi River.

The Blue Door Pub and the Blucy Burger

Address: 3448 42nd Ave S, Minneapolis, MN 55406-2811, USA

Phone: +1 612-315-2470

Website: Visit website

The Blue Door Pub introduces an innovative twist to the Juicy Lucy with its Blucy Burger. This unique offering incorporates blue cheese and garlic, setting it apart from more traditional variations which typically feature cheddar and American cheese. In addition to the Blucy, the pub boasts nine other unique cheese-stuffed burgers, showcasing toppings inspired by a range of culinary traditions.

With creative offerings and bold flavors, the Blue Door Pub continues to redefine what a Juicy Lucy can be, elevating it to an experience that is not only enjoyable but memorable for burger lovers.